NYC FERRY: HUNTERS POINT PASSENGERS LEFT STANDING AT THE DOCK – ROUTE CHANGES, HIGHER FARES AND GROWING FRUSTRATION!

 

Hunters Point South Dock

 New York City's ferry system was supposed to make life easier for waterfront residents. Instead, passengers in Hunters Point South are increasingly finding themselves standing on the dock watching their ferry arrive already packed, with little or no room to board.

What happened to NYC Ferry?

For years, the East River ferry service had a system that worked particularly well for Hunters Point residents. A ferry would arrive from East 34th Street, passengers would get off, and new passengers would board. The boat would then continue its journey across the river.

Hunters Point passengers had a reasonable opportunity to get aboard because the arriving ferry had just discharged passengers at the previous stop.

But the route structure has changed, and residents are questioning whether the new arrangement is working for their neighborhood.

HUNTERS POINT: WHY ARE PASSENGERS BEING LEFT BEHIND?

The new East River routing sends ferries through multiple waterfront communities before reaching Hunters Point South.

Depending on the route, boats serve Wall Street, DUMBO and North Williamsburg before reaching Hunters Point South.

That raises an important capacity question.

I have personally observed this problem over the past several weeks, particularly on pleasant days when more people are using the ferry. I have seen 20 or more people left standing on the Hunters Point dock because there simply wasn't enough room aboard.

Think about that. People have paid their fares, made their way to the waterfront and waited for their boat, only to watch it leave without them.

What good is a ferry schedule if passengers cannot get aboard?

NYCEDC says its route optimization was designed to increase capacity and improve service. But residents deserve to know whether the actual passenger experience matches those promises.

WHO DECIDED TO CHANGE A SYSTEM THAT WAS WORKING?

On December 8, 2025, NYC Ferry implemented a major systemwide route redesign.

The East River route was divided into two services, East River A and East River B, during weekday rush hours and non-winter weekends.

Hunters Point South is now served by East River A, while Greenpoint is served by East River B.

The city's stated goals included faster commutes, better connections, more available seats and greater operating efficiency.

But there is a difference between designing a route on paper and delivering dependable service to the people who actually use it.

If Hunters Point passengers are regularly being left behind, the city needs to investigate whether vessel capacity, passenger demand and scheduling are properly matched.

AND THEN THERE IS THE PRICE!

The price of riding NYC Ferry has increased twice in recent years.

In September 2024, the one-way fare went from $4 to $4.50.

On October 19, 2026, it increased again, this time to $5.

That represents a 25 percent increase from the original $4 fare.

A ten-trip pass is now $30.

Passengers are paying more, and they have every right to expect dependable service in return.

WHO OWNS THE COMPANY OPERATING NYC FERRY?

There is an important financial development that deserves attention.

In July 2024, Hornblower Group completed a financial restructuring that brought in new majority ownership.

The majority owner is Strategic Value Partners, LLC, a global alternative investment firm. Crestview Partners retained a significant minority interest.

Hornblower operates ferry services in several locations, including New York City.

But let's be clear: NYC Ferry itself was not sold to a private equity firm. The city retains control of the system through NYCEDC, which contracts with Hornblower's operating subsidiary, HNY Ferry II, LLC.

NYCEDC also retains the exclusive authority to establish fares and receives the ticket revenue.

The current operating agreement runs through September 2028, with potential renewal periods.

That raises a perfectly reasonable question: What performance standards does the city require from its private operator, and how does it measure whether passengers are actually receiving the service they pay for?

Boarding Signs At NYC Ferry East River Dock That Do Not Work

 

 EAST 34TH STREET: A TERMINAL THAT NEEDS ATTENTION

The problems are not limited to Hunters Point.

The East 34th Street terminal is another source of passenger frustration.

During busy periods, passengers can encounter confusing lines, unclear boarding arrangements and signs that do not adequately identify which arriving boat is serving which route.

People should not have to guess which line to stand in or run from one gate to another because they cannot get a clear announcement.

The ferry operator needs to improve its communication at the terminal. Clear electronic signs, working displays, audible announcements and properly organized boarding lines should be basic requirements.

And what about the facilities?

East 34th Street passengers need adequate bathrooms, weather protection and a comfortable place to wait.

There is little protection from the freezing winter winds that sweep across the East River. Anyone who has stood there on a cold winter morning knows exactly what that means.

NYC Ferry promotes itself as an alternative transportation system, but passengers cannot reasonably be expected to stand outside in freezing temperatures without adequate shelter.

WHERE ARE THE PROMISED BUSES?

Transportation connections are another problem.

The M34 bus is not always a convenient connection for ferry passengers, particularly when service is infrequent or poorly timed.

NYC Ferry has also referred to shuttle bus connections in its service information.

But in all my years using and observing the waterfront, I have rarely, if ever, seen the kind of dependable connecting bus service that would make these docks easier to reach.

If connecting buses are part of the transportation plan, where are they, how frequently do they operate, and where can passengers find them?

WHY SHOULD PEOPLE USE THE FERRY IN WINTER?

Hunters Point and the surrounding waterfront communities have grown tremendously. Thousands of residents live in buildings along the East River, and many would benefit from reliable ferry service throughout the year.

But winter presents a different challenge.

The wind coming off the East River can be brutal. Without proper shelter and comfortable waiting facilities, taking the ferry becomes an unpleasant experience.

Bathrooms, heated waiting areas, reliable announcements and properly coordinated transportation connections would make a substantial difference.

The city wants more riders. It should also make the terminals places where people actually want to wait.

THE CITY NEEDS TO LISTEN TO ITS PASSENGERS

NYCEDC says its route redesign followed extensive public engagement. The agency reported receiving more than 15,000 responses to its 2025 proposal.

But public feedback should not end when a new route map is approved.

The real test comes after implementation, when commuters and neighborhood residents begin using the service every day.

If people in Hunters Point are being left behind, the city needs to investigate. If East 34th Street passengers cannot determine which ferry to board, the signs and announcements need fixing. If people are paying $5 a ride, they deserve a reliable transportation service.

The question is not whether NYC Ferry can draw attractive route maps or advertise faster travel times.

The question is whether it is delivering the service New Yorkers are paying for.

WE WOULD LIKE NYCEDC AND NYC FERRY MANAGEMENT TO ANSWER SOME BASIC QUESTIONS:

How many passengers have been unable to board at Hunters Point South because vessels have reached capacity?

What is the average passenger capacity of the vessels assigned to the East River A route?

Has NYCEDC evaluated the number of passengers left behind since the December 2025 route redesign?

Why was the previous boarding arrangement changed, and can the former service pattern be reconsidered?

What improvements are planned for passenger lines, signs and announcements at East 34th Street?

Will the East 34th Street terminal receive public bathrooms and enclosed, heated passenger waiting areas?

What connecting bus service is actually available to ferry passengers, and where does it operate?

What performance requirements does NYCEDC impose on Hornblower, and how are complaints and missed boardings monitored?

New York City's waterfront communities deserve transportation that works in every season, not just on a beautiful summer afternoon.

A $5 FERRY RIDE SHOULD GET YOU A SEAT ON THE BOAT.

Times Square Gossip welcomes responses from NYCEDC, NYC Ferry management and the Hunters Point community.

Comments