DEMOCRATS HELP TRUMP SPEED UP JUDICIAL CONFIRMATIONS — CHUCK SCHUMER'S PROMISES NOW UNDER SCRUTINY
![]() |
| Chuch Schumer Gives Judges To Trump - WHY! |
In a development that has angered progressive Democrats and raised serious questions about Senate Democratic leadership, Senate Democrats allowed Republicans to accelerate the confirmation process for seven of President Donald Trump's judicial nominees on Friday, November 20.
The Senate confirmed two Trump nominees and advanced five others before leaving Washington for Thanksgiving. The procedural arrangements allow debate time on five nominations to run concurrently, potentially bringing their confirmation votes much sooner when senators return.
And here's what makes this particularly controversial: Democrats are preparing to take control of the Senate in January following their sweeping midterm victories. Yet Republicans are using their remaining weeks in the majority to push through as many of Trump's lifetime judicial appointments as possible.
WHAT EXACTLY HAPPENED?
The Senate confirmed Richard Bennett for the Southern District of Texas and Courtney Coker for the Northern District of Texas.
It then advanced five additional nominees:
Kyle Reardon, District of Alaska.
Daniel Ballou, Eastern District of Kentucky.
Bobby Long, Middle District of Florida.
Peter Mansfield, Eastern District of Louisiana.
Jesus Osete, Western District of Missouri.
The five nominees are now positioned for confirmation votes after the Thanksgiving recess.
According to Patrick McNeil of Nomination Notes, Democrats could have objected to unanimous-consent agreements that allowed Republicans to stack the procedural votes and shorten the overall timeline. No Democrat objected.
SIX DEMOCRATS ALSO VOTED TO ADVANCE A TRUMP NOMINEE.
Six Democratic senators — Catherine Cortez Masto, John Fetterman, Mazie Hirono, Tim Kaine, Jacky Rosen and Jeanne Shaheen — voted to advance Kyle Reardon's nomination.
Fetterman and Hirono also voted to advance Peter Mansfield's nomination.
These were procedural votes to advance nominations, not final confirmation votes. Nevertheless, they have intensified criticism from progressive organizations and Democratic voters.
SO WHAT DID CHUCK SCHUMER SAY?
This is where the controversy gets particularly interesting.
On November 5, Schumer told The Associated Press that Democrats would not allow Trump to put a right-wing nominee on the Supreme Court. He also made clear that his opposition would extend beyond the Supreme Court.
His words were particularly direct:
"We're not going to allow any crappy nominees" to be confirmed to the Supreme Court, lower courts or Trump's Cabinet.
That statement is now being scrutinized because Democrats subsequently allowed procedural arrangements that helped speed up several of Trump's lower-court nominations.
There is an important distinction: Schumer's November 5 statement did not promise to block every Trump judicial nominee, and he has not publicly explained the November 20 procedural arrangements in the floor remarks reviewed for this article.
On Friday, Schumer spoke about congressional oversight, Trump's handling of advanced computer chips and other administration controversies. He did not address the judicial-vote arrangements in those recorded remarks.
PROGRESSIVES ARE NOT HAPPY.
Demand Justice, a progressive judicial advocacy organization, has already criticized Schumer's approach. The organization announced a $500,000 advertising campaign criticizing him for leaving open the possibility of future deals involving Trump's judicial nominees.
Its president, Josh Orton, argued that Democrats should not support Trump's judicial nominees and criticized the willingness to allow the confirmation process to move forward.
The underlying concern is substantial: Federal judges receive lifetime appointments. Their decisions can influence civil rights, reproductive rights, immigration, labor protections and constitutional questions for decades.
TRUMP'S JUDICIAL LEGACY
If all five nominees advanced Friday are confirmed, Trump's lifetime judicial confirmation total will reach 300, according to Nomination Notes.
Republicans are attempting to complete as many appointments as possible before Democrats assume control of the Senate in January.
The incoming Democratic majority will have considerably more power to scrutinize and reject future nominees, but it cannot undo judicial appointments already confirmed.
THE QUESTION DEMOCRATS NEED TO ANSWER
Millions of Democratic voters just helped deliver the Senate to their party. They did so expecting a tougher check on Trump's agenda.
Now voters are asking why their senators allowed the outgoing Republican majority to accelerate the confirmation of more Trump judges.
Chuck Schumer has promised to stand against nominees he considers unacceptable. But promises and Senate procedure are two different things.
Democratic voters deserve an explanation of what happened, who agreed to it, and why the party did not use the procedural tools available to slow the process.
The judicial seats being filled now could shape American law long after the current political battles are over.
Times Square Gossip will be watching.

Comments